Did Bijal Patel Function as Tracy City Attorney While Her License Was Suspended Remains Unresolved

11 April 2024

Share this article

Steve Nicolaou Long Time Tracy Resident and Attorney Shines Spotlight on City Attorney and Council Ethics

Tracy taxpayers are footing the $279,807 annual salary for embattled and controversial city attorney, Bijal Patel. Her ineptness resulted in the State Bar suspending her license and ordering her to cease practicing law until she met minimum standards, and the public is still left with unresolved question about whether Ms. Patel broke the law by providing legal counsel to the city while her license was suspended.

For those needing a refresher on the issue, we covered it extensively here and here .

The most recent city council hearing did shed some light on what happened during the July 5 th Closed Session meeting that caused alarm in the community, including with prominent local attorney Steve Nicolaou.

On March 5 th , Nicolaou submitted a letter to the Tracy City Council calling out the city on a Brown Act Violation in major part because Patel attended the meeting while her license was suspended by the California State Bar. Here is what Nicolaou said:

The city’s outside counsel, Jon Natalizio from Best Best & Krieger in southern California, makes the case that the city was legally represented during the Closed Session. (Why Patel selected an unremarkable junior associate from a big firm in Los Angeles to represent Tracy in this matter remains a mystery. Wasn’t there anyone in Northern California willing to take on this case?)

Kevin Siegel of Burke, Williams, and Sorensen, who was retained to defend the city in Mary Mitracos’ lawsuit against the city, was present in the Closed Session meeting as representative for the city. According to Natalizio, this covers the city from Nicolaou’s claims.

Here is where things get murky.

Natalizio admits that Patel attended the July 5 th hearing but not as the City Attorney, instead as an appointed staff member, who had the right to attend.

The fact that Bijal Patel attended the July 5 th Closed Session or did any city business at all during her suspension by the California State Bar is at the heart of this issue. She should have never been in the room in the first place.

Just to clarify: the city’s stance is that Patel, the council appointed Tracy City Attorney, attended a meeting involving litigation with the city not as an attorney but as a city staffer. How is this possible? As of July 5 Patel had not yet told the City that her right to practice law had been suspended.

To quote the great George Strait: “If you buy that I’ll throw the Golden Gate in free…”

Instead, it’s very, very unlikely that Patel did not operate as Tracy’s City Attorney in the July meeting given that she withheld disclosing her suspension by the California State Bar from others.

She wouldn’t need to withhold providing legal advice if no one knew that she was suspended. On this front, Mayor Young and taxpayers have a right to be angry. Patel’s tight lips is not just unethical, it also put the city in threat of litigation.

One question we will not get answers for is if Bijal Patel would have been allowed to attend the meeting in July had she disclosed to the entire city council and outside counsel, Kevin Siegel, beforehand?

The answer is likely no.   Siegel, if anyone, might have advised the council and Patel to not attend out of caution. But there is no legal basis under the Brown Act for a non-attorney, that is “an appointed staff member” to attend a closed session on pending litigation. Ironically the defense raises another Brown Act violation.   Hindsight is everything but, in this regard, and for this fact alone Bijal Patel should have been fired.   It’s not too late for the city council to do the right thing and move on from Patel.   Again, let’s hope for the taxpayers sake, that local attorney Steve Nicolaou continues to press this matter forward, so more information can be made public.

< Older Post

 Newer Post >

Recent Posts

Are Politics Stopping DA Ron Freitas from Charging Tracy’s Former City Attorney?

30 September 2025
Freitas has a duty to protect the public from people providing professional services to the public when those people are not properly licensed.

Private Facebook Page Raises Questions About Nonprofit’s Political Use

24 September 2025
What is Rosario Patrick Arulappan Hiding with His Nonprofit’s Private Facebook Page?

Did Supervisor Robert Rickman Spearhead a County Donation to a Political Group Fronting as a Community Non-profit?

17 September 2025
Rosario Patrick Arulappan used his charitable nonprofit, Tracy REACH, to engage in political activity during the November 2024 Election.

The State Bar's Charges Against Disgraced Former Tracy City Attorney, Bijal Patel, Are Serious

11 September 2025
The charges filed by the State Bar of California hold potentially significant consequences for Tracy’s disgraced former City Attorney, Bijal Patel.

Sign of the Times: The Tracy Press Chases TT

29 July 2025
It’s not too often that we get the opportunity to brag about our local news blog.

FORMER TRACY ATTORNEY BIJAL PATEL IN TROUBLE WITH STATE BAR – AGAIN; FORMAL DISCIPLINARY CHARGES FILED

3 July 2025
In late June, the State Bar of California filed formal disciplinary charges in the State Bar Court against Bijal M Patel, the former but still embattled Tracy City Attorney.

English Should Resign Planning Commission Seat

30 April 2025
Alice English should not be a Planning Commissioner.

Community Input Needed: Schulte Road Warehouse Environmental Report

25 March 2025
The City of Tracy has released a Recirculated Draft Environmental Impact Report (RDEIR) for the proposed Schulte Road Warehouse project, and community feedback is encouraged.

Villapudua Family Political Favors and Miscalculations

20 March 2025
The younger Villapudua brother isn’t the only family member capable of generating headlines and creating controversies.

Stockton Councilman Brando Villapudua on the Hot Seat

11 March 2025
Stockton Councilman Brando Villapadua, the brother of former Assemblyman Carlos Villapudua, is the latest Villapudua who cannot stay out of the headlines.
Show More